Planning a wedding is no small feat, especially when you’re searching for the ideal venue that feels intimate yet spacious, romantic yet practical.
Luckily, Indiana offers some hidden gems for small weddings that provide the perfect mix of charm, personalization, and ease.
Whether you’re dreaming of a rustic barn, a historic mansion, or an urban chic venue, Indiana has something for every couple.
Let’s dive into five of the best small wedding venues that promise to deliver unforgettable moments and find the perfect intimate space to host your 2025 wedding.
Let’s get into it:
Mustard Seed Gardens
77 Metsker Ln, Noblesville, IN 46062
For couples looking for a rustic and nature filled venue, Mustard Seed Gardens in Noblesville is a magical choice. Tucked away on a quiet countryside property, this venue combines rustic charm with modern amenities. The centerpiece of the venue is a historic barn that has been beautifully restored to create the perfect wedding atmosphere. Its exposed wooden beams, twinkling string lights, and open layout provide a warm and inviting feel that’s ideal for a small, intimate wedding.
Surrounded by lush gardens and mature trees, Mustard Seed Gardens offers various ceremony options, including an outdoor garden setting where you can exchange vows under a romantic wooden arbor. Afterward, guests can gather for cocktail hour on the patio or explore the picturesque grounds while you capture stunning wedding photos.
The venue accommodates up to 150 guests, making it perfect for smaller celebrations where you can keep the guest list close and personal. The barn’s spacious yet intimate design makes every moment feel special, and the dedicated event staff ensures that everything runs smoothly from start to finish. If you’ve ever dreamed of a wedding surrounded by nature with a vintage touch, Mustard Seed Gardens is the spot for you.
The Sanctuary On Penn
701 N. Pennsylvania St., Indianapolis, IN 46204
If you want to avoid stress on your wedding day, this is the small wedding venue for you! The Sanctuary on Penn’s hospitality starts with a private tour behind their Romanesque Revival Walls crawling with ivy, so you can see if they are the best venue for you and your guests. Here, you get a full service venue that’s all about your tastes, your wishes, your family, and your beliefs.
As they put it, “It’s your wedding day, not ours… there’s no reason why you should have to compromise on anything, especially your venue.” Whether you’re looking for a fabulous DJ, a skilled hairstylist, an artistic florist, or any vendor in between – you’ll find them here! Not to mention that with two stories, a cozy patio, a lush courtyard, free city parking, and a capacity of 20-250 people there’s plenty of room for everyone!
If parking is a concern for your guests, don’t worry—The Sanctuary on Penn offers free city parking, which can be a huge stress reliever in downtown Indy. With a beautiful mix of indoor and outdoor spaces, your wedding day will be picture perfect in every way.
Laurel Hall
5395 Emerson Way, Indianapolis, IN 46226
For couples seeking timeless elegance, Laurel Hall is an opulent choice that brings a touch of historic grandeur to your wedding day. This stunning mansion, located in Indianapolis, is an architectural masterpiece from the early 1900s. Its intricate details, such as leaded glass windows, hardwood floors, and marble fireplaces, create a luxurious setting that feels both romantic and regal.
Laurel Hall offers both indoor and outdoor ceremony spaces. Imagine exchanging vows on the grand lawn, surrounded by manicured gardens and majestic oak trees, or stepping inside the mansion’s grand ballroom for an intimate indoor ceremony. The venue also features a terrace that overlooks the grounds, offering breathtaking views for post ceremony cocktails or a relaxing space for guests to mingle.
With a capacity of up to 200 guests, Laurel Hall strikes the perfect balance between being a small, intimate venue and one that can still host a decent sized celebration. The venue also offers several customizable packages, making it easy to plan a wedding that reflects your vision and style. For couples dreaming of a classic, elegant wedding with timeless beauty, Laurel Hall is a must see.
Mavris Arts & Event Center
121 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
If you’re dreaming of a modern wedding with a chic, industrial vibe, Mavris Arts & Event Center in downtown Indianapolis is the venue for you. This urban space has become a popular wedding destination, thanks to its unique blend of exposed brick, wooden beams, and floor to ceiling windows that offer stunning views of the Indianapolis skyline.
One of the key highlights of Mavris is its rooftop ceremony space, which provides a breathtaking backdrop of the cityscape as you exchange your vows. It’s perfect for couples who want that “wow” factor, especially during a sunset ceremony. Inside, the venue is divided into multiple floors, offering flexible spaces for both the ceremony and reception. Whether you’re hosting a cocktail style reception or a traditional seated dinner, Mavris allows you to customize the layout to fit your wedding vision.
With a capacity of up to 300 guests, this venue is ideal for couples who want a modern, trendy wedding without compromising on guest count. The Mavris team is also known for its exceptional service, ensuring that your day runs smoothly from start to finish. Whether you’re planning a sleek, contemporary celebration or a romantic, urban inspired affair, Mavris Arts & Event Center delivers.
The Bluffs at Conner Prairie
13400 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038
For couples who want to get away from the hustle and bustle of the city and immerse themselves in nature, The Bluffs at Conner Prairie offers the perfect riverside retreat. Nestled along the White River in Fishers, this venue is surrounded by stunning natural beauty that makes it ideal for an outdoor loving couple.
The Bluffs offer a combination of indoor and outdoor spaces, with a spacious, modern lodge that overlooks the water. Exchange vows on the picturesque outdoor terrace with the White River as your backdrop, or hold your ceremony indoors, where floor to ceiling windows allow you to enjoy the scenic views without worrying about the weather.
The venue accommodates up to 200 guests, making it ideal for medium sized weddings that still feel intimate. The indoor reception space features exposed wooden beams and a cozy, yet elegant, atmosphere that pairs perfectly with the natural surroundings. Whether you’re looking for an outdoor ceremony under the trees or a romantic indoor celebration, The Bluffs at Conner Prairie offers the best of both worlds.
Wrapping Up Small Wedding Venues In Indiana:
Indiana’s small wedding venues offer more than just a space to tie the knot—they provide experiences that reflect your personality and style. Whether you’re envisioning a rustic barn, a historic mansion, or a chic urban setting, these venues promise unforgettable moments for you and your guests.
From the heart of Indianapolis to the peaceful countryside, these hidden gems deliver intimate and personalized weddings without the hassle.
